Review of Banking
on Baghdad
By Shelomo Alfassa
- October 13, 2004
Originally published
in the Australia Jewish News
Banking
on Baghdad: Inside Iraq's 7,000-Year History of War, Profit, and Conflict
By Edwin Black 496 Pages, Hardcover ISBN 0-471-67186-X - John Wiley
& Sons October 2004
From
the birth of wandering nomadic Mesopotamians of time immemorial to the
toppling of Saddam Hussein, Edwin Black nicely documents the history
of the intriguing land of Iraq. Black tells of how the land we know
today as Iraq was integral to the world's three dominant religions,
how it was the location of which Abraham originated from and where monotheism
was promoted. Discussing a variety of themes related to the evolving
history of the land, he has prepared an enormous 496 page volume documenting
the variation of the Mesopotamian provinces, the intricate history of
the Ottoman Empire, and how post-Ottoman Iraq has grown out of a zealous
international desire for control of the multibillion-dollar petroleum
resources.
The author takes
us on a fascinating journey through time discussing ancient empires
and peoples. He discusses how long before Arabia was Islamic, Mecca
was home to Jewish tribal communities. Black details the development
of Islam, speaking of its expanding progression from a primitive desert
tribal religion founded by Muhammad to a global faith practiced in countries
all over the world. From the ancient communities which produced Babylon
(meaning gateway to God) to the various Islamic tribes and empires which
at one time or another violently took possession of the land, the reader
is taken on an exciting journey.
Opening with ancient history and building up to the modern era, the
book builds upon the desire of several different peoples, companies
and states all with a desire to compete, purchase, steal and even make
war over the plentiful oil reserves in and around Baghdad. As Mr. Black
writes:
As the nineteenth
century drew to a close, Turkish Mesopotamia and indeed the entire extended
Middle East suddenly catapulted in importance-especially to England.
No longer were the three provinces considered mere transit corridors
and stepping-stones to India and Asia. Now Mosul, Baghdad, and Basra
were coveted for their legendary but unexploited oil.
Bent on being more
"historically accurate than politically correct," the author
both skillfully and deferentially discusses the history of the land
when wars both ancient and modern, fought both on the sands of the battlefield
and in the boardrooms of Europe's corporate autocrats.
Significant aspects
of history come to life in the book, some of them not well known. Few
recognize that the Germans had a campaign to trounce over British occupied
Iraq in their goal of attaining the petroleum reserves which would have
been used to fuel combat troops on the journey to Russia. Black tells
how Hitler in fact fought the British, sending the Luftwaffe to bomb
the British air base at Habbaniya, located midway between Fallujah and
Ramadi. When it looked like Germany was about to march into Russia,
"Churchill sent a foreboding cable to President Franklin Roosevelt,
stating that if the Mideast fell to the Germans, victory against the
Nazis would be a 'hard, long and bleak proposition'".
Moreover, as a
contribution to the annals of history, Banking on Baghdad has indeed
told a vital chronicle of the Arab Jews. The author enlightens the reader
with a discussion of the Arab Jewish population which existed in Baghdad
and environs for thousands of years, until it was destroyed by the Iraqi
population in a war against its own ancient Jewish community as a spearhead
of its own anti-Zionist and nationalist crusade, ending 2,600 years
of Jewish existence.
Black discusses
the Farhud, translated as "violent dispossession" which occurred
in Iraq during 1941; the Farhud led to savage beatings and murders of
Jewish families, looting and destruction of their property and ultimately
the expulsion of 150,000 Jews from the country. He discusses how new
evidence clarifies the symbiotic relationship between the Germans and
the Arabs-and-the reason why the Arabs in Iraq targeted the Jews, even
showing that Arabs and the Nazis trained together. Notionally, it could
be said that the Farhud was to the Sephardi Jews in Iraq, what Kristallnacht
was to the Ashkenazi Jews in Austria. Demonstrating the cognizant participation
between the Islamic leadership and the Nazi party, a subject well documented,
but often overlooked by historians, the author details a powerful chronicle.
Like the author's last publication IBM and the Holocaust, this latest
book will astound its readers with new information and again make us
reexamine what we know of Hitler's scope and progression between him
and his associates in their actions to destroy the Jewish people in
line with The Final Solution.
The extensive use
of original sources is quite impressive, it has lent to uncovering important
little known facts which help tell the tale of the complex and intertwining
history of Baghdad. As the author states: "Behind every footnote
is a folder. Within every folder sit the documents supporting every
fact." Through a series of sequential events over various epochs
of history, it's explained how Iraq was molded into the boiling kettle
it is today. As a result, the reader will learn how to interpret what
Iraq was, where it has been, and where it may go.
Black arrives at
his conclusions
through an impressive amount of original research that he and an international
team have amassed. In many ways, Banking on Baghdad seeks to take up
where most histories either left off, or never expounded upon in the
first place. Banking on Baghdad will certainly open the eyes of those
who seek to learn more about a geographical area that is at the center
of the world's attention because it's a fascinating and provocative
book which will be spoken of for many years to come.