It's
All Relative: Celebrate Family History
Jerusalem
Post 20 March 2001
By
Schelly Talalay Dardashti
Jewish
Genealogy Month runs from March 25-April 23, sponsored by Avotaynu,
publishers of Jewish genealogical books and materials. This year's
theme, "Bringing Back the Names," encourages researchers
to utilize all accessible resources: the internet, cemeteries, registers,
libraries, memoirs, travels, oral traditions and more.
Contact
a local genealogical society, become a member, get involved, ask questions
- Pessah is a great time for family gatherings - and record answers
about the past for future generations.
The
Jewish Family Research Association (JFRA) is proud to once again welcome
author Dr. Sallyann Amdur Sack from Washington DC, editor of Avotaynu:
The International Journal of Jewish Genealogy. She will talk about
the Arolsen Records, and the Tracing Service of the International
Red Cross at 7 pm, Wednesday, March 28, at the Matnas Neve Eliezer,
6 Sheshet HaYamim St, Tel Aviv. All are welcome. For more information,
contact JFRA president Aviva Neeman, 03-699-2813; email, aneeman@netvision.net.il.
A
Jewish genealogy group is now being formed in Eilat. All those interested
"down south" are asked to contact JFRA vice president Rob
Sealtiel, tiigrs@matav.net.il / 03-552-1020.
And,
now for the second part of an exploration of websites for researchers
of Sephardic family history. The two columns devoted to this field
are just an introduction to Sephardic sources on the internet. Use
your search engines and discover many more country- and community-specific
resources.
"Conventional
genealogy - the collection of ancestors' names, dates of birth and
death - was not my primary interest," says Shelomo
Alfassa, director of Sephardic House research and development.
"For
genealogy to be meaningful," he says, "I thought it was
necessary not just to discover names and dates, but to reconnect to
the cultural atmosphere and milieu that defined the lives of our ancestors."
Although the everyday life of Sephardic ancestors is now gone, researchers
still want to know about their lives, what they thought, what they
talked about in the kitchen.
Sephardic
has come to mean almost any Jew who is not Ashkenazi. Although there
are wide cultural divergences within the Sephardic world, common liturgy
and religious customs constitute underlying factors of unity. Shelomo
adds that the site will encompass many other communities, including
Mizrahim/Oriental. The site began with an emphasis on Ottoman Jewry,
because the material was available - "We had to start somewhere."
As new data arrives, it will be posted.
Shelomo
adds that the communities developed under differing cultural and historical
conditions, and it is more proper to speak of Sephardi cultures, than
of one monolithic culture. The best we can do, says Shelomo,
is to offer a site where memories of all types can be saved.
"We
can't ever be 100% successful," Shelomo
says. "The data is scattered in all sorts of material and none
is labeled 'for future genealogists;' we have to look at many types
of documentation, archives, and hope it pieces together a meaningful
history."
In
the late 1990s, says Shelomo, there existed
few targeted Sephardic genealogy sites. Among them were Jeff Malka,
Harry Stein and Shelomo's own Ottoman
Sephardic site. In conjunction with Dr. David Sheby (US) and Mathilde
Tagger (Jerusalem), and other researchers, SH developed its genealogical
focus.
Shelomo
says, "The website, as well as our focus and commitment to Sephardic-oriented
genealogy has grown tremendously since its first appearance in June
2000."
"We
get hundreds of e-mail requests," he says, "Most just want
to know how to start." Readers are referred to well-written books
on genealogy fundamentals, and to their own families, the real starting
point." SH tries to convey, says Shelomo,
a beauty, intellectual depth, and great appreciation for the multi-cultural
past in which Sephardic ancestors lived, "We don't just list
names." By presenting the past with dynamic visual presentations
(rather than emphasizing name lists) it hopes to inspire readers to
attempt their own original research.
SH
is now in discussions with Crypto-Jewish and anusim communities who
feel they might have Jewish ancestry, and is striving to develop a
relationship with a major Crypto-Judaic study group to work with SH
to answer concerns and questions of those who believe they are descendents
of Conversos or other hidden Jews.
Today,
too many people claim to be expert genealogists, says Shelomo.
To be an "expert" in Sephardic genealogy one needs to be
able to read Ladino (in Rashi font and solitreo handwriting),
Hebrew, and Osmanlica. One also needs access to esoteric archival
sources in Israel, Turkey, former Ottoman lands in the Balkans, and
some European cities. Few people can do this.
Most
archives do not have a sign reading "Sephardic Genealogy;"
data must be extracted from source documents that cover many topics:
Jewish community records, tax data, foreign consular documents, trade
documents (such as French-Ottoman trade correspondence).
Resources
come from Shelomo's own research, an
internet team of dedicated professional volunteers, as well as 23-years'
worth of materials in SH archives - some from old sources, previously
unavailable in English. A translating team converts documents from
Hebrew, French, Ladino and Spanish into English.
The
role of SH, he says, is to demonstrate to people where such data exists,
although it is highly unlikely it will ever be able to document all
the family histories of all Sephardic descendents, due to catastrophies.
But
with the Net, says Shelomo, SH can create
digital archives: "We don't need original data - only facsimiles
(scans). Without a doubt, digital archiving of materials will be a
hot topic in the next few years." Future plans envision a megasite
of digital archives documenting all types of memorabilia of the Sephardic
experience and cultures. New portions are added as data arrives.
"WHAT
is unique," says Shelomo, "is that all material we post
will be printed and archived in hardcopy at the Center for Jewish
History in New York," where it will be available with archives
of the Leo Beck Institute, Yeshiva University Museum, American Jewish
Historial Socity, YIVO, and the American Sephardi Federation.
Dedicated
friends and researchers are instrumental in making the first year
a success, and connections have also been made with the Quincentennial
Foundation of Istanbul, and Rachel Bortnick's Ladinokomunita
(a living Ladino discussion list).
"In
our short eight months' online, we have facilitated many families
finding related branches," Shelomo
says."This includes many members - including myself - of our
discussion list who have discovered we are distant relatives. This
is incredible, and makes it all worth it!"
WHY
does Harry Stein produce a website devoted to Sephardic genealogical
resources?
Retired
US Army officer Harry Stein is not Sephardic, but his wife "is
a direct descendant of Don Isaac Abravanel, and from there to King
David and Batsheva." He says the family is perhaps the icon of
the Sephardic experience in Iberia, and his two children have Sephardic
lines.
"I
think everyone, as I do, wishes to give their children knowledge of
their heritage. I have always advised them that before they rush off
into the future, they must understand the past, where they came from."
His site "is dedicated to my children, my wife and those who
suffered pain."
Like
most researchers of Sephardic history, he believes in the inclusive
definition of the term: "Anyone who wants to be or who follows
the Sephardic rites," and that placing people in categories is
divisive.
"I
learned a lesson when I visited Auschwitz," says Harry. "Sephardim
from Salonika (my wife's family) and my Polish Brochsztain relatives
were killed in the same place. We are the same."
Adding
to his interest is his home in Arizona - with a large Hispanic population
- and the fact that he was stationed in Spain for three years, where
he "saw firsthand the remnants of a civilization that used to
be.
"I
know what these Conversos [those who converted to Christianity during
the Inquisition] know, but who refuse to think about it or discuss
it in public. I can see the face of Israel in their eyes."I remember
seeing an old man in Segovia trudging into what was a synagogue 500
years ago, now a Catholic Church - it hurt."
"BASICALLY,
all I wanted to do [in January 1999] was to take up some of my extra
time and do something constructive for my people - I have," says
Harry. "There was an obvious void in Sephardic genealogy, and
I filled that void by providing names and references.
"I
do almost all the research," Harry says, adding that the vast
majority of resources come from the US public library system, including
the International Library Loan program. "This is done to facilitate
the research ability of my visitors. They need a reference they can
find." Occasionally, he says, a reader will send names from a
list or book or coats of arms.
"I
used to get normal e-mails dealing exclusively with genealogy: 'How
do I find this person? How do I obtain records?' This has changed.
My site has become a site of enlightenment."
Fifty
percent of his e-mail comes from those who want to determine if they
have Jewish/Sephardic roots. Most of the time, he says, the names
provided appear to have Sephardic roots.
"People
who send me information are truly excited when they find out they
may be of Sephardic origin. Many say their reason for inquiring is
finding their names on the list and their 'unexplained' love for all
things Jewish, and/or dislike for the Church."
According
to Harry, this love of all things Jewish has given rise to a phenomena
called "hereditary memory."
"I
know every little about this, but some take it very seriously. I know
that my site is responsible for conversions. I try not to get into
that discussion because I have a genealogy site, not a conversion
of philosophy site." He has added conversion [to Judaism] links,
for example, so that he does "not have to respond the those types
of questions.
His
site offers several sections including Sephardic names, recipes, facts
and lore, heraldry and origins, and extensive links to communities
around the world, name sites, genealogy organizations, personal pages
and Sephardic music.