Who Was Nahmanides?
By
Shelomo Alfassa Image Magazine January 2006
Rabbi Moshe ben
Nahman was the leader of Spanish Jewry in the end of the turbulent thirteenth
century. He is commonly known as the RaMBaN, as well as by the Greek
name Nahmanides. Not only was he officially the chief rabbi of Aragon
and Catalonia, but he was a well respected leader of Jews everywhere.
The rabbi was born in Girona, Catalonia, Spain in 1194 (4955) and grew
to become the crown of Western European Jewish scholarship. Today we
acknowledge that his great Torá scholarship, laudable personal
life, and incisive analysis of Jewish history, remains a beacon of light
shining through the centuries.
Nahmanides was
related to the great Rabbi Yonah of Girona. Girona was a location with
a circle of mekubalim (kabbalists). This city in northern Spain is notable
because it was where kabbala flourished in the period prior to the introduction
of the Zohar. As a young man, Nahmanides was mentored in kabbala by
Rabbis Ezra and Ezriel, both who had arrived from Genova, a seaport
city in northwestern Italy.
Once an adult,
the rabbi demonstrated he was a true intellectual, a Sepharadi who set
the mold for other who followed--he was a man of faith, of Torá,
and a man of the world. He was not only a Torá commentator, Talmudist,
and kabbalist, but also a student of medicine, something which he practiced
professionally. Nahmanides studied physics as well as excelled in numerous
languages. He had been one of the earliest writers to build a bridge
of understanding between the French and the Spanish schools of Jewish
thought. On the one side, his Spanish birth and training made him open
to the world, yet he possessed the Ashkenazi devotion to the Talmud
that was already existent in France.
Despite the fact
that Nahmanides was only a boy of ten when Maimonides passed away, as
he matured, he developed an intellectual affection toward his writings.
Eventually, it would be Nahmanides that struggled to unite European
Jews that had entered into an incredible schism fueled by the works
of Maimonides. Nahmanides had great reverence for Maimonides' works,
but he disagreed with Maimonides' rationalizing of the Scriptures and
his enumeration of the 613 Commandments.
Nahmanides tried
to reconcile the supporters and opponents of Maimonides, including Rabbi
Yonah of Girona who was vehemently against Maimonides' writings. Nahmanides
defended Maimonides against his detractors, claiming that most of the
criticisms were simply false. His need to defend Maimonides ended after
Nahmanides most famous defense of Judaism ended in King Louis of France
burning all the copies of the Talmud in Paris. After this sad event,
Rabbi Yonah and other detractors of Maimonides felt that the events
in Paris were a sign that he and the others critics of Maimonides were
seriously wrong, and Rabbi Yonah and his colleagues backed down from
this matter and all matters that caused division among the Jewish People.
In the Disputation
of 1263, Nahmanides brilliantly defended the Jewish religion. This particular
disputation took place in Barcelona after King James I of Aragon ordered
the rabbi to participate in a public religious debate with the Jewish
apostate Pablo Christiani. One of the main themes of the debate was,
"Has the mashiah arrived, or is he yet to appear and redeem the
world..." Disputations such as this were not that unusual. Heretical
converts from Judaism to Christianity challenged rabbis to defend the
Talmud against challenges of anti-Christianity. Pablo Christiani demonstrated
his knowledge of the subject by basing his arguments on Biblical and
Talmudic texts. Nahmanides resisted the attacks of Christiani for four
days. He responded, taking advantage of the freedom of speech which
the king had granted him. In doing so, the rabbi destroyed Pablo's arguments.
It can be observed that the rabbi won the battle but then lost the war.
Although he won the disputes, copies of the Talmud were consequently
gathered and burned by the Church.
While the king
was very impressed by the rabbi's victory, arguments continued after
the dispute with a Dominican priest claiming that Christiani had won.
As a result of this false claim, Nahmanides wrote Sefer Havikuah (the
dispute), which detailed the event. As a result of the printing of this
book, the religious authorities charged him with humiliating the Catholic
religion. He seemingly offended the Dominicans (the promoters of the
Inquisition which would be instituted 200 years later), as well as Pope
Clement IV. Soon after, the rabbi was banished from Spain forever.
In 1267 at the
age of 72, Nahmanides emigrated to Jerusalem where he built a synagogue
in the ruins of an old Crusader-period church. This synagogue was used
by all sections of the Jerusalem community for centuries, growing significantly
as the Jewish population bloomed following the conquest of Eretz Israel
in 1517 by the Turks; the Turkish Ottoman Empire permitted Jews who
had been expelled from Spain to settle there. Today, the Nahmanides
or RaMBaN Synagogue, is the largest active Ashkenazi synagogue in the
Old City of Jerusalem.
Nahmanides spent
the last years of his enormously productive life finishing his monumental
commentary on the Torá, he had begun in Spain. He eventually
settled in Acco, north of Haifa, where he continued to write. Through
his commentary, he offered a clear view and explanation of the Torá,
showing the moral and ethnical lessons that it contained. In many places
throughout his commentaries, he introduced midrashic and kabbalistic
explanations. Another gem of those final years was Igeret HaRaMBaN,
the letter in which he sets forth eloquently and concisely the ethical
principles by which his son should conduct himself.
The elderly rabbi
remained in Acco while waiting for a decision that would permit his
return to Spain. This decision never materialized and he never returned
nor saw his family again. Nahmanides died in 1270. It is believed he
is buried at the foot of Mt. Carmel.